Every now and again we run into a business owner who wants to know whether he or she should transfer ownership of their close corporation to their family trust.
So while I’m on the subject of close corporations I thought you might find this interesting!
Let’s start off with how many members are allowed…
A close corporation is allowed to have between 1 and 10 members (This bit I remembered from business economics in Matric! 😆 ).
Can juristic persons become a member?
A juristic person is a company or close corporation, and no, they cannot become a member of a CC.
Only natural persons can become members, however…
The following ‘persons’ are allowed:
- An executor or administrator of an insolvent estate of a member. Either of these persons may be a company or close corporation.
- A trustee of a testamentary trust. This trustee may be a company or close corporation but it may not be a beneficiary of this trust. This trust may also not be controlled by a beneficiary of the trust in question.
And what if I’m a trustee on my family trust?
A trustee of an inter vivos trust is also allowed to be a member of a CC.
And what’s the benefit of that?
Two benefits spring immediately to mind…
One – owning your member’s interest of a close corporation in an inter vivos (otherwise known as a discretionary) trust would ‘freeze’ the value in your personal estate.
Have I perhaps lost you?
Let’s assume that you sold your membership in a CC to your family trust for a cool million Rand. 20 years later and your share of that CC is now worth R20 million. Owning a R20 million asset in your personal estate could leave you with a massive tax problem. Currently, only R3,5 million of your estate which is not left to a spouse, is estate duty-free.
So R20 million less R3,5 million equals R16,5 million. That R16,5 million would attract tax at 20% which means R3,3 million in taxes!
Now weigh this up against transferring ownership to a trust when your share was only worth R1 million. Since R3, 5 million is estate duty-free, the R1 million would be free of all estate taxes!
Two – capital gains tax.
South African Revenue Services (SARS) was kind enough to grant the small business owner a capital gain tax exemption of R900, 000 but this is subject to certain conditions being met.
Anything more than this and capital gains tax is payable.
“Hang on a moment…I’m not going to sell me member’s interest so should I worry about capital gains tax?”
Yes and no.
You see, when you eventually pass away (and this happens to the best of us!), it’s viewed as a disposal for capital gains purposes.
You could effectively end up paying 10% tax on any gain in your member’s interest!
So now you have two good reasons to own a CC in a family trust, but…
There are two conditions!
- A juristic person such as a company or close corporation may not be a beneficiary of your trust.
- If the number of beneficiaries of your trust – when added onto the members of the CC – exceeds 10, then the membership of the trustee – and the trust – cease permanently. Huh? Suppose the close corporation has 8 members including yourself as trustee of your trust, and your trust has 3 beneficiaries. Together this makes a grand total of 11 people which permanently disqualifies the trust from ever being a member again.
So there you have it in a nutshell!
PS: Once again I am deeply in gratitude to the authors of The South African Financial Planning Handbook 2011 which was used as a reference work.
Can we help you with anything? Leave your details below and we will be in touch.
Leave us your thoughts in the comments section below.
Please rate this post